Source: CNN
During Friday Follies, Fox News Laura
Ingraham describes the Democratic town hall on LGBTQ
rights from the previous night as an event of shameless pandering by Democrats
to the social justice warriors. Raymond
Arroyo says, “Laura, it’s almost embarrassing at
this point. CNN, as you referenced earlier did another 2020 town hall marathon.
And this may tell us how 2020 might go: it tanked their ratings. The equality
town hall gave the Dem(ocratic) candidates an opportunity to curry favor with
their reliable LGBTQ constituency.” They mention how Cory Booker “throws”
himself at one of the questioners, “You are a beautiful man. Make our President
bald again.” Joe Biden embellishes his story of a first encounter with a gay
couple. And Kamala Harris with her statement, “My personal pronouns are she,
her, and hers.” Raymond Arroyo calls this a “pander-fest” that lasted for hours
and hours that did not help the ratings, being that already 82 % of the LGBTQ
community votes Democrat.
This past Thursday night, October 10, 2019, CNN hosted a four and a half hour
live Democratic town hall focused on LGBTQ rights. Airing on the eve of
National Coming Out Day, this segment allowed 2020 Democratic presidential
candidates to voice what they will do to combat violence against the LGBTQ
community.
With two months remaining this year, there have already been 19
transgender women murdered this year. In 2018, there were a
total of 26
deaths of transgender women, a majority being Black
transgender women. These women are being killed by family members, partners,
and strangers. While some of these cases were clearly anti-transgender crimes,
others were deaths created by the very common consequences of coming out.
Transgender women are oftentimes fired from their jobs because of their
transgender status; oftentimes, they are being kicked out of their homes
because they receive no tolerance or acceptance from family. To make matters
worse, now homeless, many transgender women are being denied access to homeless
shelters because of their status.
South Bend, Indiana mayor Pete Buttigieg was the only openly gay candidate at the
forum on Thursday. The CDC says if certain infection rates continue,
one in two Black gay men in the United States will be diagnosed with HIV within
their lifetime. On reducing HIV contractions among the African American
population, Buttigieg stated, “First of all, we got to make sure that access to
treatment is equitable and available to everybody. (That) Is why I propose
Medicare for all who want it. We take a version of Medicare; we can make it
available for everybody who wants it. But whether you’re on that public plan,
that I want to create, or on a private plan, we require that everyone be
treated with equity. And that includes not just treatments for HIV, which are
shockingly expensive. But also prep and other things that can be done to
prevent the transmission of HIV.”
But are Democrats becoming extremist advocates for LGBTQ rights? Former
Republican Senator Beto
O’Rourke declared, “There can be no reward, no
benefit, no tax break for anyone or any institution (or) any organization in
America that denies the full human rights and the full civil rights of every
single one of us.” O’Rourke is meaning to point out that no religious
institution can remain tax-exempt without approving of the LGBTQ community
and/or not legitimizing their unions. In other words, churches will be fined
for not accepting LGBTQ or its members. Is that an attack on churches that
infringes on citizens’ right to freedom of religion?
There should come a time that everyone accepts LGBTQ as legitimate, but also a
time that LGBTQ respects that others are entitled to their own opinions, as
long as those opinions do not cause harm to another. Gallup
Data taken from 1.6 million adults finds that 10
million Americans – 4 % of the population – identify as LGBTQ. But demographer
Gary J. Gates believes the true percentage is greater than that. Gates
speculates, “(there are) discouraging indicators of contemporary LGBT(Q)
prejudice – like the fact that close to 30 % of Americans think that same-sex
sexual behavior should be illegal – as a sign that ‘we’re still quite a bit
aways’ from being confident that all survey respondents are comfortable
disclosing their sexual and gender identity.”
How did fellow LGBTQ community members feel about the Democratic town hall? Katie
Herzog says, “LGBTQ people are not a monolith. We
all have different values and opinions on public policy, and there are fierce
debates within this population on matters ranging from trans people in sports
to whether or not same-sex marriage is actually good for queer people. The
candidates at this forum don’t understand that – and why would they? Aside from
Mayor Pete (who, according to some of the queer press, hardly counts), these
are just not their issues. Attempting to wade into them on a live TV broadcast
will just show actual queer people how little they get it.”
During the town hall, there were two interruptions by audience members that
brought important information to the forefront of the CNN special. First, trans-women
of color protestors displayed banners of “We are
Dying” and “Do Something” while chanting “Trans-Lives Matter.” Then later,
activist Blossom
C. Brown takes the microphone away from a
questionnaire to call out CNN for not having any black trans-women speak at the
LGBTQ town hall. “CNN you have erased Black trans-women for the last time…” she
says, “I am an extraordinary Black trans-woman, and I deserve to be here, too.”
In an episode of Unfit To Print, Amber Athey, the Daily Caller’s White House correspondent, summarizes the
town hall in her daily report, “CNN tried to prove how “woke” they were by holding
an LGBT theme town hall for the Democratic Presidential candidates. So, each
candidate went up on stage in turn and answered questions about their platforms
for the LGBT plus communities. And it quickly backfired though on both the
Democratic Presidential candidates and the hosts of the event of CNN as they
quickly were proven not be nearly as “woke” as they thought they were. Just
goes to show how you can never really satisfy some of these far left-wing
contingents who are constantly demanding further and further identity politics
to the point where no one can keep up with what they actually want.” Overall, Black
trans-women were not impressed with the CNN’s segment of LGBTQ town hall, and
they even felt further victimized by their own “supporters.”
Democratic Town Hall on LGBTQ Rights: Real Possibilities or a Bunch of Boloney?
Written By: Jessica Gibson
Sign Up For Updates
Get the latest updates, research, teaching opportunities, and event information from the Democratic Erosion Consortium by signing up for our listserv.
0 Comments