Nov 15, 2020

A Cause To Celebrate?

Written by: Alexandra MorkTyler Woolf

This past week, The United States underwent one of the most tense elections in our history. The probability of violence with the victory of either candidate was strong. Cities all across the country boarded up businesses, closed public spaces, and and even called in national guard support in fear of the violence which would ensue. The city of Boston, my home, was prepared to meet civil unrest unlike anything we had seen before. After an extensive five day process of counting ballots of both in person and mail in voters, a victor was finally decided. 

It was a beautiful sunny day in Boston. The temperature was unseasonably warm. Residents of Boston had been closely watching the results in hope a winner would finally be announced. Around noon time on that Saturday, Joe Biden was named the winner of the United States Presidential election. For the first hour after that announcement, there was a bit of a pause. People weren’t sure what was to come. Were angry Trump supporters going to be causing trouble? Was the destruction the city had prepared for at hand? What transpired next, no one was prepared for. It started with a few zealous Biden supporters, dancing and celebrating out front of the Massachusetts Statehouse. As the day progressed the numbers grew exponentially. What went from an isolated celebration, turned to a party, then into something massive. 

By roughly two o’clock in the afternoon, hundreds of thousands of people lined the Boston Commons. Though I am far from a Biden-Harris supporter, I felt I had to see the spectacle. My friends and I, who could hear the celebration from our dorm, walked to the Commons to see what was happening. Upon arrival, I was unsure if what I was witnessing was a political rally, or a Red Sox world series championship parade. There was a  sea of people as far as I could see. Vendors handed out t-shirts saying “Trump Pence out now!!” Or much more vulgar slogans. Celebrants climbed street signs, and held up home made poster boards. A car parade passed, drivers honked their horns, blasted music, and held Biden-Harris signs out of their windows. Streets were blocked off to make room for the festivities. It was very reminiscent of a pre-covid world. 

At first I was a bit shocked, for a few reasons. I personally didn’t see Biden as a particularly exciting candidate, so the celebration was a bit foreign to me. But what really was surprising to me was the disregard of Covid. Now I will preface this by saying, I personally have not had much fear of covid, but the same can not be said for many of my peers. Many of my friends who would refuse to go out to restaurants, movie theaters, or public gyms, and strongly reprimanded people for gathering flocked to this massive celebration. I guess that peoples’ love of Biden (or hatred of Trump) was strong enough to overcome whatever fear was present. 

In my eyes this celebration carried much more significance than a simple rally. To me it signaled a change in attitude from the more left wing of our country. At this time, COVID cases have been on a steady rise nationally. Each day I read a new news headline about how we have set records for single day cases. Left leaning news outlets constantly reprimand Trump for his Covid response, and the American public for being antagonistic to State mandated restrictions.  Yet what I saw on that day was those same people breaking their own dogma. Does this mean that the more progressive wing of the United States has had a shift in attitude towards the virus? Possibly, but no matter what the city of Boston as a collective will have to deal with whatever consequences come with an event of such magnitude.

I believe what we saw both in Boston, and nationally was a great example of the erosion of American political efficacy. Citizens on both sides of the political spectrum are becoming more and more fed up with government imposed restriction. Rather than trust the rule of government, citizens chose to celebrate and are prepared to accept the consequences that come with that. With a new president coming into power, I am curious to see if this trend of lack of trust in government will continue. 

Sources

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/06/us/Epidemiologists-coronavirus-protests-quarantine.html
https://www.bbc.com/news/world-54477523
https://www.wbur.org/news/2020/11/07/photos-boston-cambridge-celebrate-biden-harris
https://www.nbcboston.com/news/local/photos-people-take-to-streets-of-boston-to-celebrate-bidens-victory/2225696/

Sign Up For Updates

Get the latest updates, research, teaching opportunities, and event information from the Democratic Erosion Consortium by signing up for our listserv.

Popular Tags

Popular Categories

2 Comments

  1. Preeya Patel

    Hi, nice to see another Bostonian! I was also really concerned by the congregation of people in the streets after the election because it definitely felt hypocritical to me (I understand that there is this idea that if you are wearing a mask all is well — which is simply not the case). I wonder, however, if this represented a general frustration with stay at home orders themselves or if it just came from a longing to be with others during a joyous moment (not so much celebrating Biden but rather the end of Trump). For the past few months, I have gotten the sense that many liberals are starting to venture out of their homes more but are still cautious of COVID (wearing masks, getting tested, avoiding indoor spaces/large gatherings). Most people I saw at the celebrations were at the very least wearing masks (which could not be said about the recent march from Trump supporters in Washington DC) which suggests that they haven’t forgotten or rejected COVID protection rules entirely.
    I think that this post is interesting because it makes me wonder: if your thesis is correct and liberals are getting fed up with COVID restrictions, how would the Republican party react? I think that Democrats approval of COVID restrictions has been labelled by Republicans as part of their “elitism” (a.k.a. I am better than you because I wear a mask). I would assume that if Democrats start rejecting COVID restrictions after all of the negative comments they made about Republicans doing the same, it would only serve to confirm Republican sentiments that Democrats are hypocritical elites.

  2. Tyler Eld

    Tyler,

    Very interesting take on the post-election event that occurred outside of City Hall. I think you’re right to point out the importance of mask wearing/social distancing in a time like this. Also interesting is the way you frame the celebration-goers and their culpability: are the willing to sacrifice a potential spike in COVID cases?

    I passed by this gathering as well, though it was earlier in the day and not as crowded as it would soon be. I did not join the crowd; I watched from a street over for a few minutes and moved on. Something interesting that I noticed was that there were Biden-Harris posters as well as Trump-Pence flags raised in the same mass of people. Perhaps the pro-Trump people left as the day went on, but it was far more tumultuous when I passed by. I honestly couldn’t tell for sure if it was an anti-Biden protest or a pro-Biden celebration.

Submit a Comment