Apr 4, 2021

Democratic Erosion in Haiti

Written By: Sarah Saintius
Protests in Haiti, 2020.

Haiti has long been in a state of revolt, as far back as the colonial age. Since Haiti declared independence in 1804, the country has had no luck in maintaining a stable democracy. From funding militias of slave masters to embargoes from nearly every world power, and even forcing Haiti to pay billions of dollars in reparations to those slave owners, the country was never given a chance to develop. The geographic position and natural resources were also a lot of interest. Haiti is full of gold, bauxite (aluminum product), oil, fertile land, and is positioned in central Caribbean. Over the course of its history, five different world powers have tried to annex the country.
Haiti is considered a hybrid regime, their switch from authoritarian regime to democratic regime is still in transition. There are four characteristics that typically provide conditions for democratic backsliding (whether alone or paired) including polarization, racism/nativism, economic inequality, excessive executive power. We see examples of polarization during Duvalier’s presidency when upper class and upper middle-class citizens of Haiti were in agreeance with how Duvalier was running the country even though poor black masses were suffering because of it. Racism in the country started with the separation of Black people and “mulattos” which was still an issue in the country under Duvalier’s regime. Colorism in Haiti is started out a three-tiered social structure putting lighter skinned people at the top and darker skinned people at the bottom. In the middle were people called “freedman” who were the descendants of slave owners and slaves. Ritualistic skin bleaching to lighten one’s skin, brown paper bag tests to verify one’s skin tone. Economic inequality affected poor laborers in the country pushing them to leave their homes in rural areas and go to the cities. The cities become overpopulated, over polluted, and dangerous. Excessive executive power with Duvalier and his son Jean-Claude from 1957-1986. Keeping Duvalier in power for 29 years then passing the power down to his son rather than having a fair election when passing down the power breeds lots of corruption and erodes democracy. The current administration of Jovenel Moïse has brought about levels of corruption not seen since the end of the Duvalier regime in 1986. In 2019 there was an embezzlement of 1.459 billion Euros from an oil agreement with Venezuela, that was intended for developmental and infrastructural projects. Haitian businesspeople, the political class and the president himself are found to be involved. law enforcement in the country is corroded and criminal gangs take control; horrifying massacres are common in the country. In 2018, 71 people were killed in the massacre of La Saline, a destitute neighborhood of Port-au-Prince (the capital). Independent investigations have pointed out the connection of the government to the bloodbath, since then three similar atrocities have occurred. Today in 2021 Haiti faces the issue of displacement, they remain susceptible to natural disasters and tropical storms which destroy shelter for the people of the country. Rights to health, water, and food since the country’s more vulnerable communities continue to face environmental risks such as widespread deforestation an limited access to safe water and sanitation. A corrupt criminal justice system, the prison system is extremely overcrowded and many of the inmates are living in inhumane conditions. The overcrowding is due to the high number of arbitrary arrests. Illiteracy is a major problem and approximately 50% of all Haitians age 15 and older are illiterate. The quality of education is generally low and 85% of schools are run by private entities that charge school fees can become too expensive for low income families. There has been no accountability for the past abuses and no reparations to the country. Gender-based violence is a widespread problem; Haiti does not have specific legislation against domestic violence, sexual harassment, or other forms of violence targeted at women and girls. Among the survivors of the events that occurred in La Saline massacre are 11 women and girls were gang raped and received no medical support or counselling. People who identify as LGBT suffer high levels of discrimination; the Haitian senate has passed two anti-LGB

Sign Up For Updates

Get the latest updates, research, teaching opportunities, and event information from the Democratic Erosion Consortium by signing up for our listserv.

Popular Tags

Popular Categories

2 Comments

  1. Donnell Suggs

    I really Enjoyed reading this post, the detail on Haiti’s history was exactly accurate and the information was short and sweet. I was able to leave with more information without having multiple pages of information pushed at once. Knowing that Haiti has struggled with keeping their democracy intact for a long period of time do you think there will ever be a time the citizens are satisfied with there countries government. Like you originally stated in your post events like “(funding militias of slave masters to embargoes from nearly every world power, and even forcing Haiti to pay billions of dollars in reparations to those slave owners,”). The country was never given a chance to develop, so with that being the case I think the government in will progressively get worse. Haiti also has had many terrorist groups that are at war with other groups which puts a strain on the democratic structure.

  2. Lauren Randall

    Sarah did a great job on their discussion. They were able to properly add relevant information pertaining to Haiti’s history that eventually led to the erosion of their democracy. Great job mentioning Haiti’s regime to give more insight on why their democracy growth is so stagnant. I liked how Sarah gave examples of polarization to help the reader further understand why this is a problem. It is important to mention Haiti’s difficult past with colorism to highlight where a lot of their social/political problems also steam from which they have done. They did a good job making sure to include stats into the blogs for evidence for their findings. Haiti has had a troubled past when it comes to democracy, which initially started with the Europeans and their push to make sure the country stayed unstable to discourage other countries from fighting for freedom.

Submit a Comment